![]()
|
||||||||
|
||||||||
Methodology The knife is fixed in the machine and the blade is mounted in a position with the edge vertical. The blade is moved back and forth whilst a pack of special testing paper is lowered onto the blade. The blade cuts through the paper and the sharpness is then measured.
Testing of Knives in Original Condition Sharpening of Knives |
CATRA Cutting Test to ISO 8442.5 |
| Maker and Knife | Test# |
ICP | lmprovement. | LIFE TCC | lmprovement | |
| OXO 14781 Santoku knife, |
221 |
Factory sharpen |
67.0 | % | 211.5 | % |
225 |
Whetstone sharpen |
121.9 | 81.94% | 750.7 | ||
| HENCKEL 4 Stars 31119-180 Santoku knite |
213 |
Factory sharpen |
105.8 | % | 473.0 | % |
248 |
Whetstone sharpen |
117.2 | 10.78% |
625.8 | 32.30% |
|
| WUSTHOF LE CORDON BLUEU Chef's knife |
218 |
4581/20 Factory sharpen |
95.7 | % | 307.6 | % |
244 |
4581/20 Whetstone sharpen |
121.4 | 26.86% |
696.2 | 126.33% |
|
| WUSTHOF GOURMET, Santoku |
215 |
4188/7 Factory sharpen |
104.9 | % | 476.6 | % |
239 |
4188/7 Whetstone sharpen |
114.1 | 8.8% |
624.1 | 30.95% |
|
| SABATIER LION Cook knite, |
437 |
Factory sharpen |
22.4 | % | 44.2 | % |
463 |
Whetstones harpen |
122.7 | 447.77% |
641.7 | 1,351.81% |
|
| VICTORINOX Chef's knite, |
436 | 52000.19 Factory sharpen |
106.4 | % | 403.5 | % |
464 |
52000.19 Whetstone sharpen |
124.5 | 17.01% |
613.0 | 51.92% |
|
| GLOBAL FAKE knife, (Made in China) |
314 |
G-2 Factory sharpen |
10.5 | % | 24.7 | % |
320 |
G-2 Whetstone sharpen |
88.5 | 742.86% |
490.1 | 1,884.21% |
|
| KATAOKA M11 CLAD Vegetabl, 16cm. |
365 |
Factory sharpen |
80.6 | % | 272.9 | % |
374 |
Whetstone sharpen |
153.8 | 90.82% |
1,213.5 | 344.67% |
|
| KATAOKA M11 CLAD Vegetable, 18cm. |
367 |
Factory sharpen |
110.7 | % | 412.9 | % |
375 |
Whetstone sharpen |
192.9 | 74.25% |
1,280.9 | 210.22% |
|
| KAI SHUN DM-0706 Chefs knite, |
205 |
Factory sharpen |
108.0 | % | 487.5 | % |
236 |
Whetstone sharpen |
127.6 | 18.15% |
711.3 | 45.91% |
|
| PORSCHE P02 Santoku knite, |
444 |
Factory sharpen |
89.7 | % | 307.0 | % |
452 |
Whetstone sharpen |
116.0 | 29.32% |
794.2 | 158.70% |
|
| ROSENDAHL Chef's knite |
402 |
SP-1 Factory sharpen |
85.2 | % | 235.3 | % |
413 |
SP-1 Whetstone sharpen |
143.4 | 68.31% |
953.2 | 305.14% |
|
| ROSENDAHL Cook knife, |
408 |
SL-1 Factory sharpen |
104.4 | % | 388.6 | % |
414 |
SL-1 Whetstone sharpen |
142.0 | 36.02% |
818.1 | 110.52% |
|
| ROSENDAHL Vegetable knife, |
438 |
SP-3 Factory sharpen |
109.9 | % | 405.8 | % |
456 |
SP-3 Whetstone sharpen |
124.4 | 13.20% |
924.6 | 127.85% |
|
| ROSENDAHL Vegetable knife, |
449 |
SL-3 Factory sharpen |
97.5 | % | 350.4 | % |
451 |
SL-3 Whetstone sharpen |
114.7 | 17.64% |
933.9 | 166.52% |
|
| GLOBAL Cook knife, |
316 |
G-2 Factory sharpen |
127.7 | % | 781.5 | % |
354 |
G-2 Whetstone sharpen |
146.0 | 14.33% |
1,129.3 | 44.50% |
|
| GLOBAL Vegetable knife, |
226 |
G-5 Factory sharpen |
118.8 | % | 617.1 | % |
306 |
G-5 Whetstone sharpen |
121.9 | 3.0% |
1,070.4 | 73.46% |
|
| GLOBAL SANTOKU knife, |
207 |
G-46 Factory sharpen |
94.3 | % | 412.0 | % |
286 |
G-46 Whetstone sharpen |
137.6 | 45.92% |
1,062.3 | 157.84% |
|
| GLOBAL SANTOKU knife, |
465 |
GS-35 Factorysharpen |
106.4 | % | 441.3 | % |
| 468 | GS-35 Whetstone sharpen | 105.8 | -)1% | 1,037.2 | 135.03% | |
| KATAOKA Tamahagane Vegetabl, 16cm. |
585 |
Factory sharpen |
99.4 | % | 403.3 | % |
588 |
Whetstone sharpen |
170.9 | 71.93% |
1,283.6 | 218.27% |
|
| KATAOKA Tamahagane Vegetable, 18cm. |
586 |
Factory sharpen |
108.1 | % | 438.5 | % |
587 |
Whetstone sharpen |
168.0 | 55.5% |
1,306.1 | 197.86% |
|
| GLOBAL SANTOKU knife, |
613 |
G-46 Factory sharpen |
102.3 | % | 461.9 | % |
641 |
G-46 Whetstone sharpen |
127.6 | 24.73% |
922.4 | 99.70% |
|
| GLOBAL SANTOKU knife, |
602 |
GS-35 Factorysharpen |
110.4 | % | 481.1 | % |
| 607 | GS-35 Whetstone sharpen | 141.0 | 27.7% | 1,085.8 | 125.69% | |
| RAADVAD, Denmark SENSEI Cooking, 19cm |
881 |
Factory sharpen |
70.6 | % | 257.7 | % |
971 |
Whetstone sharpen |
127.7 | 80.88% |
836.9 | 226.76% |
|
| HENKELS, Germany MIYABI 500S CHUTOH 16cm |
891 |
Factory sharpen |
96.6 | % | 335.0 | % |
990 |
Whetstone sharpen |
127.5 | 31.99% |
842.3 | 151.43% |
|
| WEBER, Germany 14116 Vegetable knife |
882 |
Factory sharpen |
123.1 | % | 539.7 | % |
944 |
Whetstone sharpen |
149.8 | 21.69% |
1,127.4 | 108.89% |
|
| ROSENDAHL, Denmark Graud Cru 16800 COOK 20cm |
880 |
Factory sharpen |
83.8 | % | 249.9 | % |
943 |
Whetstone sharpen |
149.0 | 77.8% |
1,051.1 | 320.61% |
|
| YAXELL, Japan Chef's knife DAMASCUS 69 Layer |
888 |
Factory sharpen |
117.1 | % | 507.5 | % |
942 |
Whetstone sharpen |
143.9 | 22.89% |
1,016.5 | 100.3% |
|
| KAI SHUN, Japan Kagi 8"Chef's. KDM-0006 |
890 |
Factory sharpen |
107.0 | % | 464 | % |
940 |
Whetstone sharpen |
156.7 | 46.45% |
1,008.4 | 117.33% |
|
| KAI SHUN, Japan SG-0404 Chef's, Cobalt m.v. |
886 |
Factory sharpen |
147.4 | % | 710.6 | % |
937 |
Whetstone sharpen |
164.6 | 11.67% |
1,077.5 | 51.63% |
|
| Robert Welch, UK 20cm.(8") Cooks knife |
875 |
Factory sharpen |
74 | % | 593.1 | % |
878 |
Whetstone sharpen |
135.9 |
|
1,008.4 |
|
|
| CATRA Cutting Test to ISO 8442.5 G-2 Cook, Factory sharpen ![]() |
CATRA Cutting Test to ISO 8442.5 G-2 Cook, Wet stone sharpen ![]() |
|
CATRA Cutting Test to ISO 8442.5 G-2 Cook, minoSharp by 10 strokes ![]() |
CATRA Cutting Test to ISO 8442.5 ![]() |
|
| | download | | ||